Monday, March 1, 2010

The Japanese Avant Garde in Paris

by Angela Marzan

Yuniya Kawamura’s “The Japanese Revolution in Paris Fashion”: It was first published in 2004 in Fashion Theory, Volume 8, Issue 2. The author is an assistant professor of sociology at FIT. She is also professionally trained as a fashion designer and a patternmaker at Bunka School of Fashion in Japan, Kingston Polytechnic in England, and FIT. She completed her Ph.D. dissertation at Columbia University. At the time the article was published, Kawamura was studying Japanese street style in New York and Japan.

Kenzo F 2009

The article “adopts a production-of-culture theoretical approach” (195). It discusses the introduction of Japanese designers into the French fashion industry from 1970 to 2003, during a time when haute couture was losing its primary clientele. Of particular interest are the designers and their relationship to the French fashion system. The designers that she speaks of are Rei Kawakubo, Issey Miyake, Yohji Yamamoto, Hanae Mori, and Kenzo.

Kenzo S/S 09 Ad campaign by Mario Sorrenti

Kenzo Takada was born February 27, 1939 in Himeji, Japan. He is a Japanese fashion designer and the founder of Kenzo. He shortly attended the University of Kobe and in 1958, he began attending the fashion school Tokyo's Bunka Fashion College, which had just begun to admit male students. He settled in Paris in 1964 where he tried to gain a place in the fashion environment by attending shows, making contacts with the media, and selling sketches. Around 1970, Kenzo began to gain success. His first men's collection was launched in 1983. In 1993 the brand Kenzo came under ownership of LVMH. He retired in 1999, but returned as decoration designer in 2005.

Miyake, SS 2008

Issey Miyake FW 2009

Issey Miyake was born April 22, 1938. He is a Japanese fashion designer known for his technology-driven clothing designs. He studied graphic design at the Tama Art University in Tokyo, graduating in 1964. After graduation, he worked in Paris and New York City. Returning to Tokyo in 1970, he founded the Miyake Design Studio. In 1994 and 1999, Miyake turned over the design of the men's and women's collections Naoki Takizawa, so that he could return to research full-time. In 2007, Naoki Takizawa was replaced by Dai Fujiwara.

Yamamoto F 2007



When speaking of her article, Kawamura offers a definition for the difference between fashion and clothing: I introduce Fashion-ology, a scientific and sociological investigation of fashion as a system that constitutes institutions, organizations, groups, designers, gatekeepers, events, and practices, and that contributes to the making of 'fashion'. The structural nature of the system affects the legitimation process of designers' creativity, and the inclusion and exclusion of designers in/from the system… A systemic analysis of fashion helps us make a distinction between fashion and clothing which are two independent, autonomous entities although they are often utilized interchangeably. Clothing is a material production while fashion is a symbolic production. Clothing is a necessity while fashion is an excess. Clothing has a utility function while fashion has a status function. Clothing is found in any society where people clothe themselves while fashion must be institutionally constructed and culturally diffused.


Comme des Garcons S 2008

Comme des Garcons F 2009



She also defines social capital as connections within the industry, particularly in regards to Mori, which Kawamura posits is fundamental in Mori’s place amongst haute couture houses in France. Her belief is that despite the avant garde quality of the Japanese designers, they are still resigned to conforming to the laws of the French fashion system, explaining that these designers only show in Paris, not Japan. She furthers this idea by stating that if a designer wishes to succeed, they must submit to the French fashion system. Thus, in order to make it in the fashion world, one must submit to the Western fashion power.


Hanae Mori 2001, 2004


Hanae Mori was born January 8, 1926. She is the only Japanese woman to have presented her collections on the runways of Paris and New York, and the first Asian woman to be admitted as an official haute couture design house by the fédération française de la couture in France. She graduated from Tokyo Women's Christian University and then married and attended dressmaking school. She opened her first atelier in 1951 and in 1965, she presented her first New York collection, "East Meets West". Twelve years later, she opened an haute couture showroom in Paris, leading to her appointment as a member of La Chambre Syndicale de la Couture Parisienne. In 1997 Dominique Sirop became the grand couturier.


The Avant Garde


Viktor & Rolf S 2010

Deconstruction and the avant garde are subjective terms to describe designers that often overlap. Both make more art like creations however deconstruction designers are normally more quiet and cerebral which avant garde designers are more theatrical and flamboyant.

Use of the term “avant garde” was defined in a book by John Berger “Theory of the Avant Garde” in which he isolated the historic era of art politically reacting against systems during WWI & II. This was art work not connected to either academia or the market. The women associated with the avant garde artists experimented with traditional forms of fashion. They considered what they were making as either art or costumes. There seemed to be an understanding of the separation between art and reality which has decreased over time.

Duchamp, LHOOQ 1919 & Fountain 1917

Elsa Sciaparelli, 1937 and Meret Oppenheim, Turkey Shoes, nd.

The term haute couture describes one of a kind designs, typically displaying extreme aesthetics. Most haute couture is just an example of a designer’s talent and is not for sale, however with growing interest from celebrities for black tie and other events, some couture is fitted or duplicated upon request.


French couture is regulated by an industry governing body, the Fédération française de la couture, du prêt-à-porter des couturiers et des créateurs de mode created in 1973. It consists of the Chambre Syndicale of haute couture (high fashion), created in 1868. The Federation also has a fashion school, the Ecole de la chambre syndicale de la couture parisienne (created in 1928). Only companies officially recognized by the Chambre Syndicale are licensed couture, which are all French corporations, but designers in Milan, London and NY also use the word couture for custom clothing.

Balenciaga 1967-1968, couture single seam wedding gown


From the end of the war in 1945 until the mid 1960’s most designers focused on mass sales. Creative extravagance was observed in French couture by Chanel, Dior, Balenciaga, and YSL. By the late 1960’s the social climate began to change encouraging more creative experimentation.

Andre Courreges: Born in 1923, he studied engineering then entered fashion in 1965. He came at the right moment of revolutionary thinking and the space age.

Courreges, 1967 & 1966

He claims to have “invented” the mini skirt (along with Brit Mary Quant at the same time, a quantum invention), and the heelless gogo boot. He emphasized synthetic materials and geometric shapes. The design and the presentation challenged the status quo.


Courreges, Qui Estes Vous Polly Magoo?, 1966

Paco Rabanne: Like Balenciaga he came from Spain to France and first worked making jewelry for the design houses. He was recognized for space age costume design for Barbarella. Like Courreges it was his emphasis on synthetics and the new forms they could make that made his work seem ahead of its time from standard designers.

Rabanne, 1967 & 1968

Thierry Mugler: Began as a designer with the first collection in 1973. Has emphasized wide padded shoulders, solid colors, pvc and synthetics. Has inconsistently been able to produce couture in part because of lack of sales but has continued by creating costumes for Lady Gaga and Beyonce.

Mugler, Lady Gaga & 1997

Designers can also create forward thinking, innovative and dreamlike creations, that seek to make fantasy a reality but may not always end up in reality. The challenge of the avant garde is not only in the unrealized future of the designs or the limitations of their wear-ibility but their claim to be fashion rather than art or theater…?

Amaya Arzuaga, Spanish Fashion Week, 2009


Alexander McQueen: Alexander McQueen was the controversial son of a taxi driver and graduate of Central Saint Martins. He created his own line and designed for Givenchy from 1996-2001. His label is now owned in majority stake by PPR Gucci group.

F 2008
F 2009

F 2009
S 2010

Viktor & Rolf are a Dutch design team of Viktor Horsting and Rolf Snoeren. They initially worked at Margiela and presented their clothing in art galleries and unauthorized shows during fashion week. They consciously use form as a means of communicating a message and often embellish existing forms.


F 2004, F 2005, SS 2006


Fall 2007

S 2010



Thursday, February 25, 2010

Margiela & the Antwerp 6


Margiela, S 2009

Often associated with one another, Martin Margiela and the designers known as the Antwerp Six graduated from the Antwerp Royal Academy of Fine Arts at the same time. Margiela first worked for Gaultier and began to build his company based on a low profile brand presence and innovative designs. In 2002 he sold his company to Deisel and has played a decreasing role in the design. It is now called “Maison Martin Margiela.

Margiela 1991 & 1998

Maison Margiela S 2008

Margiela jacket made form a Swiss Army bag, 2006

Margiela negated the fashion industry. Using a cerebral, almost scientific method for his label, he has had employees dress in lab coats. He also does not advertise and the stores are very discreet.




The Antwerp Six refers to an important group of deconstructionist fashion designers graduating from Antwerp's Royal Academy of Fine Arts between 1980-1981. They shared a radical vision that established Antwerp as a notable location for fashion design. The breakthrough occurred in 1988 as the group rented a truck and set out for London fashion week with respective collections.

The Antwerp 6 in 1988

Together they showed deconstruction as a making and unmaking of forms and codes including exposing the backstage and form of presenting. Below clockwise from top left Ann Demeulemeester,
Marina Yee, WalterVanBeirendonck,
Dries van Noten,
Dirk Van Saene, Dirk Bikkembergs.


Walter Van Beirendonck


Dirk Bikkembergs

above 1991 and below 2009

Ann Demeulemeester

1989 and below F 2009
F 2009

Dries van Noten

F 2009

Dirk Van Saene


Marina Yee


Together these designers successfully bring the power of the fashion system into question on all levels from design to consumer good. Their influence is not in the commercial sector like power designers but rather in the creative realm where they have empowered many young designers.